
Medical Malpractice
Medical Malpractice Investigation of Dr. Bethany Cataldi

Investigating Claims By Former Patients of Dr. Bethany A. Cataldi
CohenMalad, LLP is speaking with former patients of Dr. Cataldi who may have been victims of medical malpractice, healthcare fraud or other injustices.
Our firm's medical malpractice attorneys are investigating potential claims related to Dr. Bethany A. Cataldi, a Highland, Indiana physician who earlier this year was sentenced to 97 months in federal prison after pleading guilty to healthcare fraud. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, Dr. Cataldi billed Medicare and private insurers for thousands of balloon sinuplasty procedures that she did not perform.
Dr. Cataldi was the sole owner of the Center for Otolaryngology and Facial Plastic Surgery in Highland, Indiana. Federal prosecutors said she sought approximately $50 million for non-existent procedures and was paid nearly $20 million. The DOJ also reported that approximately $460,000 in fraudulently obtained funds came directly from individual patients through co-insurance payments.
Free, Confidential Medical Case Review
If you were treated by Dr. Cataldi, received bills related to balloon sinuplasty or sinus procedures, paid co-insurance for treatment, or have questions about whether your medical care, billing, or insurance claims were affected by this scheme, our medical malpractice team wants to hear from you.
The purpose of our investigation is to help former patients understand how they may have been affected, what their legal rights are and help determine whether pursuing justice through the civil law system is in their best interest.
It is important to remember that Indiana's statute of limitations continues to run. Assessing your legal rights as quickly as possible, so you can make an informed decision on next steps while you still have a legal option.
Indiana Medical Malpractice Attorneys Fighting for You
CohenMalad, LLP is Indiana’s largest plaintiffs’ firm, and has been a fierce advocate for injured patients and families since 1968.
Our medical malpractice attorneys are compassionate, experienced and have the resources to investigate complex surgical injury cases.
If you or a loved one are a former patient of Dr. Bethany Cataldi, contact CohenMalad, LLP today for a free, confidential medical case review.
There is no cost to speak with our team, and there is no obligation to move forward. We encourage you to contact us today to help determine whether medical malpractice was committed, and what your legal options are should you wish to move forward with a civil lawsuit.

Update
6/10/2026
Medical Malpractice Case Consultation
Contact us now if you are a former patient of Dr. Bethany Cataldi